Mon–Fri 10–6 · Sat 10–4 · Sun by appointment 104 N Washington Ave, Dunellen, NJ 08812 (opens Google Maps) (732) 529-6746 kasmultiservicesllc@gmail.com

Payroll

Employee or independent contractor? Why the difference matters

Classifying a worker correctly affects payroll taxes, paperwork and your risk as a business owner. The questions that matter.

Published · KAS Multiservices

When you pay someone to work for your business, one of the first questions is whether they are an employee or an independent contractor. The answer changes your responsibilities.

Why it matters

  • Employees: you withhold income tax, pay employer payroll taxes, give them a W-2 and may owe unemployment insurance.
  • Contractors: you generally do not withhold, and if you pay them enough during the year you send a 1099-NEC.

The questions that decide it

Classification depends on the real working relationship, not just what the agreement calls it. Common factors include:

  • Who controls how, when and where the work is done.
  • Whether the worker uses their own tools and sets their own hours.
  • Whether they offer services to other businesses.
  • Whether the work is a core part of your regular business.

New Jersey looks closely

New Jersey applies its own tests for unemployment and wage purposes, and they can be stricter than the federal approach. A worker treated as a contractor for one purpose may be considered an employee for another.

What to do

Review each working relationship before the first payment, keep written agreements and invoices for contractors, and collect a Form W-9 from each contractor before paying them. If you are unsure, ask before payday, not after.

We can review how you pay people and set up payroll for employees. Book a consultation.

Related services

More from the blog

All articles

Book a consultation

Get the help you need, without the wait

Book an appointment online or call us. Let KAS help with your financial needs.